Finding the right sunscreen for my kid has taken me a few summers of trial and error. Some types of sunblock are too shiny, some leave a white sheen, and some are too thick. I’ve tried all the brands, and the best sunscreen for kids is listed below. Here are the top sunblock brands for picky kids, all approved by the ultimate critic: my kid.

For my daughter, the sunscreen she likes depends on where she’s applying it. She swears by each of these for different uses: Supergoop! and SunBum for everyday face protection, and Neutrogena Beach Defense for her arms and legs.

Best sunscreen for face: Supergoop! Unseen Sunscreen Stick – SPF 40

Supergoop! Unseen Sunscreen is an invisible, broad-spectrum sunscreen that’s perfect for a kid’s face. Lightweight, completely transparent, and non-greasy, it’s the one my daughter loves for camp and whenever she’s outside.

• Completely invisible with no white cast
• Smooth, non-greasy texture
• Broad-spectrum SPF 40 protection

Best sunscreen for body: Neutrogena Beach Defense Kids Sunscreen Stick SPF 60+

Neutrogena Beach Defense Kids Sunscreen Stick SPF 60+ is a lifesaver for the pool or beach. My daughter swears by this one for all-day sun protection. It’s easy to apply, water-resistant, and the high SPF makes it perfect for long summer days. The only downside is it can get a little shiny looking if you try it for your face.

• SPF 60+ for strong sun protection
• Convenient stick for quick application
• Water-resistant

Best sunscreen for smelling good: Sun Bum Kids SPF 50 Clear Face Stick Sunscreen

Sun Bum Kids Clear Face Stick is perfect for my daughter’s sensitive skin. My daughter loves this for quick touch-ups or when we’re out running around—the the clear stick is small and easy to apply without the mess.

• Clear, no white residue
• Easy to apply on face and small areas
• Fun, kid-friendly branding
• Sweet banana scent

Buying sunblock for sensitive kids

For picky kids, each sunscreen has its moment. Supergoop! Unseen is our everyday face keeper, Neutrogena Beach Defense is perfect for full-body protection on beach or pool days, and Sun Bum Clear Face Stick is great for sensitive skin and quick touch-ups. With these three, skin protection is easy and something my daughter is actually cool with.